Goodbye Yellow Brick Road.jpg

2020 Album Draft- Round 4- Pick 6- Eclectic Music Lover-selects- Elton John- Goodbye Yellow Brick Road.

Eclectic Music Lover’s blog can be found at- https://eclecticmusiclover.com/

My pick for Round 4 is the monumental double album “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road” by Elton John. And while I don’t feel it qualifies as a true masterpiece, I think it comes pretty close, and is an album I’d want to have with me on that desert island. Though my younger sister became a rabid Elton John fanatic from the moment he released his tender and heartfelt debut single “Your Song” way back in 1970, it took me a while to warm up to him and his music. I mean, I liked him well enough, but can’t say I became a huge fan of his until the release of “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road” (though I now more fully appreciate the brilliance of his early albums like “Tumbleweed Connection” and “Madman Across the Water”.)

Since its release in 1973, the album has sold over 30 million copies worldwide, and is widely considered John’s finest work. It contains several of his signature songs like “Bennie and the Jets”, “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road”, “Candle in the Wind” and “Saturday Night’s Alright (For Fighting)”, as well as the epic – and my personal favorite – “Funeral For A Friend/Love Lies Bleeding”. The album was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 2003, and ranks #91 on Rolling Stone magazine’s most recent list of the 500 greatest albums of all time, although at the time of its release, the magazine gave it a negative review: “ This new record is a big fruity pie that simply doesn’t bake. But, oh lord, how it tries .”

Bernie Taupin wrote all the song lyrics for the album over a period of two and a half weeks, then John composed most of the music in three days while staying at the Pink Flamingo Hotel in Kingston, Jamaica. He’d wanted to write and record the songs in Jamaica partly because the Rolling Stones had just recorded “Goats Head Soup” there. Unfortunately, difficulties with the piano and sound system, as well as logistical issues arising from the Joe Frazier-George Foreman boxing match and unrelated political protests taking place in Kingston, caused him and his musicians to rethink their plans. They ended up recording the album at Chateau d’Herouville, the same studio in France where he’d previously recorded “Honky Château” and “Don’t Shoot Me I’m Only the Piano Player”. Though not a concept album per se, many of its songs touch on disillusionment and a nostalgia for a childhood and culture left in the past.

Given all the flamboyance, tabloid sensationalism, fame and infamy of Elton John’s illustrious and colorful career, it’s easy to sometimes overlook the fact that, in addition to being a great composer and vocalist, he’s also an incredible pianist. Perhaps no other song showcases his piano-playing skills than the epic album opener “Funeral For A Friend”. Together with its companion track “Love Lies Bleeding”, the fantastic 11-minute long piece is a grandiose and dramatic melding of classical and progressive rock, and was reportedly conceived by John as the kind of music he wanted played at his own funeral. I was blown away the first time I heard it, and to this day it remains my all-time favorite of his many great songs. The bittersweet lyrics of “Love Lies Bleeding” tell of a lost love: “ Oh it kills me to think of you with another man. I was playing rock and roll and you were just a fan, but my guitar couldn’t hold you so I split the band. Love lies bleeding in my hands

Next up are three of his most famous and beloved songs. The beautiful piano-driven ballad “Candle in the Wind” is a sort of tribute to Marilyn Monroe, with lyrics spoken from the perspective of a fan trying to reconcile the myths and legends attached to the legendary and tragic actress. (The song was later reimagined in 1997 as a tribute to Princess Diana after her own tragic death.) Davey Johnstone’s guitar ​work is particularly outstanding on this track. The stomping glam-rock gem “Bennie and the Jets” is, according to Bernie Taupin, a satire on the greed and glitz of the early 70s music industry. John was initially set against releasing it as a single, as he thought it would flop, but it went to #1 in the U.S. and Canada, and endures as one of his most popular songs and biggest hits. The title track “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road” is probably my second-favorite track on the album, as I love the piano-driven melody and soaring vocal harmonies in the choruses.

John’s brilliant piano skills are also strongly evident on the folk-inspired “This Song Has No Title”, the exuberant “Grey Seal”, the jazzy, cinematic torch song “I’ve Seen That Movie Too” and the dramatic tour de force “The Ballad of Danny Bailey (1909-1934)”, with its bouncy honky-tonk style piano and sweeping orchestrals. One of the songs that piqued my sexual curiosity when the album came out (I was 19 at the time) was “All The Girls Love Alice”, with lyrics that tell a tragic story of a young lesbian who died in the streets. Though the lyrics are depressing, I love the driving beat, abrasive synths and distorted psychedelic guitars that give the song such an edgy and dangerous vibe.

Side 4 of the album is the weakest part of the album overall, keeping it from being a perfect work in my opinion, though none of the tracks are terrible. John and company dial up the energy on “Your Sister Can’t Dance (But She Can Rock’n’Roll)” (probably my least-favorite track on the album, as I’m also not a fan of his big 50s throwback hit “Crocodile Rock” either) and “Saturday Night’s Alright (For Fighting)”, which I do like, mainly for its edgy vibe, great piano and guitars. “Roy Rogers” and “Social Disease” have an Americana vibe, a genre John has visited many times through his career with varying degrees of success, and he succeeds pretty well here. The final side of the album is redeemed by the sultry closing track “Harmony”. The song is a piano-driven love song with more of those sweeping orchestrals and John’s wonderful vocal harmonies. He assures his recalcitrant loved one Harmony that she and he are pretty good together and may as well make a go of it: “ Harmony and me, we’re pretty good company. Looking for an island in our boat upon the sea .”, ending things on an optimistic note.​


  1. I love everything about this album, and concur that the best track is “Funeral For a Friend/Love Lies Bleeding.” That doesn’t change the fact that I will turn up the car stereo to disturbing levels for both “Saturday Night’s All Right for Fighting” and “All The Young Girls Love Alice.”

  2. This one was in the running for me. Kind of depends on the day as far as which of Elton’s early albums is my favorite. However, on a desert island you get more with a double album. The radio hits are kind of worn out as individual songs, but in the context of the whole album they’re still great. I’m more of a fan of tracks like I’ve Seen That Movie Too, Danny Bailey, etc. at this point. A most excellent album choice.

    • Thanks Stephen. I actually grew tired of “Bennie and the Jets” decades ago, as it was (and still is) overplayed to death on the radio, though I still appreciate its brilliance. As you state, there are lots of terrific deep cuts that make this double album such a gem.

  3. Good pick and nice write-up. Classic indeed, but IMHO the last great Elton John record. The last in a mighty impressive run. Watch me ponder his catalog here.

  4. Thanks Mike. Yes, like a lot of artists & bands, John’s sound became increasingly pop over the years, though I do love his 1991 hit “The One”, a gorgeous and under-appreciated song with some of his best ever piano work. Nice commentary of his early albums!

  5. Scooped! Oh well – a great writeup Eclectic ML! This one definitely was coming up soon in my top 10, and would be on my personal list of ten to take with me too. One of the very first albums I had as a kid and one which still sounds as good to me over 40 years later. To me there’s no bad track on it although my personal least favorite is “Saturday Night’s Alright for Fighting” – but after seeing the ‘Rocketman” film, it makes more sense in context. To me even the largely unknown tracks like “Danny Bailey”, “Grey Seal” and “All the Young Girls Love Alice” rank with his best songs and the best of that era. Glad there’s another lover of the record among us!

  6. Jeff, good choice. Elton dominated the radio waves for a long time, and his music kept us impressed and singing along. I remember the first time hearing “Candle in the Wind” and being overcome with emotions, thinking of Marilyn tragic end. Excellent write-up!

  7. Excellent review of that album. I was exposed to his early to mid-seventies singles while growing up which are brilliant but I have recently listened to some of his 70s albums including this one. Funeral For A Friend/Love Lies Bleeding is epic and the title track…no matter how many times I’ve heard the song…I can’t get enough to it. Elton made some of the best pop music of the 70s.

  8. It’s been a long time since I listened to Elton. Your piece has me curious on some of the tunes I have forgotten. No doubt about the guys talent. His run of early albums was a good one. I like the Honky Chateau record. I guess CB will be busting out some Elton today. Thanks.

  9. Those early Elton albums up to say A Single Man- were strong- Yellow Brick Road would be my favorite- great selection. One of the great singles artists of the decade but I think his albums are often over looked- from that period.

  10. I like Elton John’s early phase and find petty much all of his albums between his debut and the mid ’70s have at least one or two great tunes. I’m not sure which record I would pick, but “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road” is a good choice. I also think “Too Low for Zero” from v1983 is a pretty decent album overall.

Comments are closed.